Best Lancaster Movers
Want help with the heavy lifting?
Updated Jun 18, 2025
Looking for reliable Lancaster movers? See our top 10 recommended movers in Lancaster, NY based on extensive analysis. We analyzed 39 moving companies in Lancaster across 15,666 review data points and more than 25,000 movers nationwide using our 11-point rating system to help you determine which Lancaster moving company to hire. See the top 10 Lancaster movers, get data-based information on Lancaster moving costs, the cheapest movers in Lancaster, and our top recommendation for Long distance movers.
Key Takeaways:
- Good Neighbors Moving is our overall top recommended moving company in Lancaster
- Pete's Moving LLC is the most affordable movers in Lancaster
- Expect to spend somewhere between $888 and $2,423 on local Lancaster moving services
- Our rankings and results are unbiased & backed by data… NOT paid promotions
Best Moving Companies in Lancaster, NY
| Rank | Company | Score | BBB Rating | Avg Move Duration | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Good Neighbors Moving | 9.39 | N/A | 4 hours | |
| 2 | Alpaca Moving Services Inc. | 9.31 | N/A | - | |
| 3 | Brody Moving Services LLC | 9.12 | NR | 3.25 hours | |
| 4 | Wayfinder Moving Services | 9.09 | A | 3.5 hours | |
| 5 | Stellar Movers | 9.08 | NR | 2 hours | |
| 6 | Interior Moving Services, Inc. | 8.98 | A+ | 3.5 hours | |
| 7 | Truck & A Trailer Moving LLC | 8.98 | NR | - | |
| 8 | Joey Z's Moving | 8.91 | NR | - | |
| 9 | WNY Moving | 8.87 | NR | - | |
| 10 | Wayfinder Moving Services - Amherst NY | 8.70 | NR | - |
Our Top Recommendations
Good Neighbors Moving
Best moving company overall in Lancaster, NY
Good Neighbors Moving
100 Schultz Rd, West Seneca, NY, 14224
11-Point Rating
Best moving company overall in Lancaster, NY. Good Neighbors Moving takes the #1 spot for our overall ranking and is the top recommended movers in Lancaster.
Good Neighbors Moving is the number 1 ranked moving service in Lancaster, NY with an overall score of 9.39 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 95.47% of all movers in New York and the top 96.69% of moving companies nationwide. They score better than 38 other Lancaster moving companies and better than 1,194 movers in New York.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Good Neighbors Moving & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.84 | ↑ 18.6% | 153 | 1 | 99.4% | |
| Punctuality | 9.62 | ↑ 20.3% | 44 | 1 | 97.8% | |
| Affordability | 9.18 | ↑ 21.0% | 28 | 1 | 96.6% | |
| Communication | 9.46 | ↑ 26.5% | 38 | 1 | 97.4% | |
| Stick to Prices | 6.91 | ↑ 15.0% | 1 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Speed | 9.84 | ↑ 16.6% | 72 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 9.89 | ↑ 13.9% | 84 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.78 | ↑ 21.3% | 122 | 1 | 99.2% | |
| Professionalism | 9.88 | ↑ 20.5% | 98 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Conflict Handling | 9.08 | ↑ 108.6% | 7 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.84 | ↑ 23.3% | 66 | 0 | 100.0% |
Recent Good Neighbors Moving Reviews
Quality - 9.84/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.62/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 9.18/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 9.46/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 6.91/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.84/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.89/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.78/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.88/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 9.08/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.84/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Good Neighbors Moving
N/A
Licenses
We do not currently have license data to display for Good Neighbors Moving
Detailed Customer Insights
Based on our analysis of Good Neighbors Moving's customer reviews:
4 hrs
Local Move Duration
based on 4 reviews
Alpaca Moving Services Inc.
Middleport, NY, 14105
11-Point Rating
Alpaca Moving Services Inc. is the number 2 ranked moving service in Lancaster, NY with an overall score of 9.31 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 93.75% of all movers in New York and the top 95.1% of moving companies nationwide. They score better than 37 other Lancaster moving companies and better than 1,173 movers in New York.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Alpaca Moving Services Inc. & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.66 | ↑ 16.4% | 45 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Punctuality | 9.30 | ↑ 16.2% | 10 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Affordability | 8.84 | ↑ 16.6% | 8 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Communication | 9.16 | ↑ 22.6% | 11 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Speed | 9.53 | ↑ 13.0% | 17 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 9.55 | ↑ 10.0% | 18 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.60 | ↑ 19.0% | 40 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Professionalism | 9.43 | ↑ 15.0% | 17 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.51 | ↑ 19.2% | 19 | 0 | 100.0% |
Recent Alpaca Moving Services Inc. Reviews
Quality - 9.66/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.30/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 8.84/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 9.16/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.53/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.55/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.60/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.43/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.51/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Alpaca Moving Services Inc.
N/A
Licenses
State & federal license information
New York Moving License
Status: Denied (last checked: 9/28/26)New York Moving License Information
- License Number: 43278
- License Status: Denied
- Date Issued: -
USDOT Interstate License
Status: Authorized for Interstate Moves (last checked 10/11/26)- USDOT: 4378696
- MC: 1716092
- ENTITY TYPE: Carrier
1
Registered Trucks, Tractors, or Vans
1
Registered Drivers
7/30/25
Most Recent USDOT Update
1
Annual Interstate Miles (2024)
Detailed Customer Insights
We do not currently have insights to display for Alpaca Moving Services Inc.
Brody Moving Services LLC
Lancaster, PA
11-Point Rating
Brody Moving Services LLC is the number 3 ranked moving service in Lancaster, NY with an overall score of 9.12 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 91.76% of all movers in New York and the top 90.57% of moving companies nationwide. They score better than 36 other Lancaster moving companies and better than 670 movers in New York.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Brody Moving Services LLC & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.56 | ↑ 15.1% | 179 | 7 | 96.2% | |
| Punctuality | 9.52 | ↑ 19.0% | 64 | 2 | 97.0% | |
| Affordability | 8.90 | ↑ 17.3% | 35 | 3 | 92.1% | |
| Communication | 8.94 | ↑ 19.7% | 63 | 7 | 90.0% | |
| Stick to Prices | 7.90 | ↑ 31.4% | 18 | 5 | 78.3% | |
| Speed | 9.84 | ↑ 16.7% | 71 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 9.62 | ↑ 10.9% | 127 | 4 | 96.9% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.43 | ↑ 16.9% | 181 | 11 | 94.3% | |
| Professionalism | 9.37 | ↑ 14.3% | 128 | 8 | 94.1% | |
| Conflict Handling | 7.71 | ↑ 77.3% | 9 | 2 | 81.8% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.54 | ↑ 19.5% | 90 | 4 | 95.7% |
Recent Brody Moving Services LLC Reviews
Quality - 9.56/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.52/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 8.90/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 8.94/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 7.90/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.84/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.62/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.43/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.37/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 7.71/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.54/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Brody Moving Services LLC
N/A
Licenses
State & federal license information
New York Moving License
Status: Active (last checked: 7/04/25)New York Moving License Information
- License Number: 8920677
- License Status: Active
- Date Issued: -
USDOT Interstate License
Status: Authorized for Interstate Moves (last checked 10/11/26)- USDOT: 3242388
- MC: 1686594
- ENTITY TYPE: Carrier
3
Registered Trucks, Tractors, or Vans
6
Registered Drivers
12/10/25
Most Recent USDOT Update
80,000
Annual Interstate Miles (2025)
Detailed Customer Insights
Based on our analysis of Brody Moving Services LLC's customer reviews:
3.25 hrs
Local Move Duration
based on 4 reviews
Wayfinder Moving Services
75 Comet Ave, Buffalo, NY, 14216
11-Point Rating
Stellar Movers
84 Hartwell Rd, Buffalo, NY, 14216
11-Point Rating
Interior Moving Services, Inc.
157 La Grange Ave, Rochester, NY, 14613
11-Point Rating
Truck & A Trailer Moving LLC
North Tonawanda, NY, 14120
11-Point Rating
Joey Z's Moving
North Tonawanda, NY, 14120
11-Point Rating
WNY Moving
East Aurora, NY, 14052
11-Point Rating
Wayfinder Moving Services - Amherst NY
Medina, NY, 14103
11-Point Rating
How Much Do Movers Cost in Lancaster, NY?
The average moving cost in Lancaster, NY is $1,211, which is based on an analysis from 27 customer reports across 5 different moving companies. In general, expect to pay somewhere between $888 and $2,423 for a typical move.
- Median Reported Cost: $1,211
- Expected Range: $888 - $2,423
- Expected Time To Complete: 3.25 hours
- See detailed Lancaster Moving Costs for a full breakdown
| COMPANY | MEDIAN REPORTED MOVING COST | AVG MOVE DURATION |
|---|---|---|
| Two Men and a Truck | $651 | 4.5 hours |
| Sheridan Brothers Moving | $888 | 3 hours |
| Joe's Moving Company | $1,211 | 3 hours |
| PODS Moving & Storage | $2,423 | - |
| Wayfinder Moving Services | $4,628 | 3.5 hours |
*Please be aware that the listed prices derive from historical customer feedback spanning several years and might not mirror the exact current rates of a company. Additionally, the anticipated cost range provided represents the 25th to 75th percentiles from the comprehensive reports of all Lancaster-based companies in our dataset.
How we ranked the top Lancaster movers
Why you should trust us
We take reviews seriously to protect people just like you! Our team has been crunching data on moving companies since 2010. Our math-based ranking system uses data, manual review, and statistical analysis to help you hire the best movers in Lancaster, NY.
Rating Methodology
Here's the methodology we used to come up with the best movers in Lancaster:
Our original review-based ranking algorithm
We started with a total of 39 companies that offer moving services in the Lancaster area.
From these 39 companies, we analyzed a total of 9,045 reviews dating all the way back to July 2010.
We also reviewed a total of 27 state and federal moving licenses from these 39 companies and 125 different 3rd party review and social profiles.
Each of the ~9,000 reviews was scored according to our detailed 11-point rating criteria
This gave us a total of 15,666 data points to compute individual company scores.
Reviews are time-weighted so that more recent reviews carry more weight. This helps you understand how a mover is doing today... not 5 years ago. We have 883 Lancaster moving company data points from the past 2 years that carry more weight.
Bayesian averages calculated to fairly account for the differences between companies that are newer(like Wayfinder Moving Services ) vs older more established companies (like Interior Moving Services, Inc.).
The Great Guys Moving 11-Point Rating Breakdown
Our 11-point rating criteria scores every Lancaster moving company across 11 of the most important criteria for a succesful moving experience.
Quality
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Punctuality
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Affordability
How affordable was the moving service?
Communication
Responsiveness before, during, and after the move.
Stick to Prices
Was the final price consistent with the original quote?
Speed
Efficiency without taking unnecessary time to increase costs.
Friendliness
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly on moving day?
Will Hire Again
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again.
Professionalism
Did the moving crew behave professionally on moving day?
Conflict Handling
How well the company responds to accidents and issues.
Precision & Care
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get damaged or lost?
Charts & Visualizations
With 15,666 data points across 39 moving companies and 9,045 reviews, we've got a lot of data to work with. Here are some of the charts and visualizations we've created to help you understand the moving industry in Lancaster.
Comparing ratings, review history, and total data points
Bubble size represents the number of analyzed data points. Hover over bubbles for details.
Ranking history
How the currently ranked top 10 Lancaster movers have performed over time
11-Point Rating Comparison
Detailed breakdown of Lancaster moving company 11-point ratings
New York-wide 11-Point Percentile Comparison
See how the top movers in Lancaster compare to all movers in New York
 Quality |  Punctuality |  Affordability |  Communication |  Stick to Prices |  Speed |  Friendliness |  Will Hire Again |  Professionalism |  Conflict Handling |  Precision & Care | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Wayfinder Moving Services Exceptional9.09 | 83 | 76 | 70 | 70 | 88 | 80 | 93 | 87 | 94 | 82 | 87 |
2 | Stellar Movers Exceptional9.08 | 86 | 96 | 75 | 93 | 74 | 90 | 94 | 87 | 88 | 81 | 71 |
3 | Interior Moving Services, Inc. Superb8.98 | 87 | 73 | 76 | 91 | 58 | 78 | 91 | 82 | 87 | 85 | 91 |
4 | Truck & A Trailer Moving LLC Superb8.98 | 93 | 97 | 89 | 78 | 68 | 98 | 95 | 96 | 92 | 51 | 91 |
5 | Joey Z's Moving Superb8.91 | 80 | 74 | 65 | 74 | 44 | 77 | 73 | 83 | 82 | -- | 79 |
| 6 | Wayfinder Moving Services - Amherst NY Fabulous8.70 | 80 | 74 | 31 | 81 | 75 | 62 | 73 | 81 | 78 | 73 | 80 |
Percentile Ranking
List of All Lancaster Moving Companies Analyzed
See all of our Lancaster moving company reviews
- Helping Hands Movers
- Wayfinder Moving Services
- Diamond Moving & Storage
- Corrigan Moving Systems
- Zito Movers, Inc.
- A & L Moving
- Pete's Moving LLC
- U-Pack
- Interior Moving Services, Inc.
- Sheridan Brothers Moving
- Joe's Moving Company
- Clark Moving & Storage
- Brody Moving Services LLC
- Movers & Co.
- The Moving Doctors, Inc.
- Novo Moving
- Truck & A Trailer Moving LLC
- Two Men and a Truck
- PODS Moving & Storage
- Fisher North American
- Second2None Moving
- Kiper Moving and Transportation
- Joey Z's Moving
- Stellar Movers
- Keith's Moving Company
- Advanced Moving 716, LLC
- Baaahh Movers
- Wayfinder Moving Services - Amherst NY
- Buffalos Best Movers
- Sow Smooth Movers And Cleaners
- WNY Moving
- Alpaca Moving Services Inc.
- Four Corners Moving Services
- NK Packing-Moving Specialist LLC
- Premier Relocations
- Buffalo Moving Co
- Good Neighbors Moving
- BuffBins LLC
- Buffalo Moving Solutions
Frequently Asked Questions About Moving in Lancaster
How much should you tip movers in Lancaster, NY?
Offering a fair tip to your movers in Lancaster can show gratitude for their hard work, especially if they're hauling heavy furniture near Cayuga Creek or along Broadway. Most people add 10–20% of the total moving cost or about $5 per mover per hour. This simple gesture acknowledges their dedication and keeps everyone motivated. You can also offer them a quick break with a refreshing Tim Hortons coffee or a cold soft drink to help them power through the day.
Is it cheaper to make a DIY move in Lancaster?
Some movers in Lancaster choose a do-it-yourself approach, hoping to cut costs by renting a truck and boxing everything themselves. However, keep in mind that gas, equipment rentals, and moving supplies can add unexpected expenses, especially when navigating routes like Walden Avenue. Also, hauling items on your own can take longer without extra help. Before going this route, check these local truck rental options to compare prices and availability.
Should I hire labor-only movers?
If you only need help loading and unloading in Lancaster, consider hiring labor-only movers. This option lets you manage your own transportation while still getting professional support for heavy lifting, whether you’re on Central Avenue or closer to Transit Road. It’s a practical way to keep costs down while benefiting from movers who know how to handle bulky items without damaging walls or floors.
What if I need to move something special like a piano or pool table?
When you have items like a piano or a pool table, relocating in Lancaster can feel more complex than a standard move. That’s why it helps to work with specialists. Trust piano movers to protect your instrument from damage, and rely on pool table movers to handle disassembly, transport, and reassembly without scratching your table or floors. These pros know how to handle oversized, fragile items so you can relax.
