Best Buffalo to Indianapolis Movers

How Much Do Buffalo to Indianapolis Movers Cost?

Moving 503 miles from Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN will typically cost between $2,000 and $5,500 to hire full service movers. See the chart below for a detailed breakdown by home size.

Pro tip for the cheapest long distance move

Find long distance movers in Indianapolis that already have a booked job heading from Indianapolis to Buffalo. Their moving truck would be making the trip back to Indianapolis from Buffalo entirely empty. If you can find a Indianapolis moving company willing to move your stuff on the return leg, you'll score a real deal!

Moving Containers: A cheaper Buffalo to Indianapolis moving option

Hire local Buffalo movers for the pickup location at an hourly rate. They can quickly load your moving container. When your container is dropped off at your new home, hire Indianapolis movers to unpack the container and move you into your new home. You'll have to piece this Buffalo to Indianapolis move together yourself with at least 3 different companies. Taking on this scheduling responsibility will save you a little money by moving with this strategy.

How we ranked the top Buffalo to Indianapolis movers

Why you should trust us

We take reviews seriously to protect people just like you! Our team has been crunching data on moving companies since 2010. Our math-based ranking system uses data, manual review, and statistical analysis to help you hire the best Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN long distance movers.

Rating Methodology

Here's the methodology we used to come up with the best movers for the Buffalo to Indianapolis moving route:

Our original review-based ranking algorithm

We started with a total of 23 companies that offer interstate moving services in both the Buffalo and Indianapolis areas.

From these 23 companies, we analyzed a total of 4,918 reviews dating all the way back to August 2005.

We also reviewed a total of 0 state and federal moving licenses from these 23 companies and 95 different 3rd party review and social profiles.

Each of the ~4,000 reviews was scored according to our detailed 11-point rating criteria

Reviews are time-weighted so that more recent reviews carry more weight. This helps you understand how a mover is doing today... not 5 years ago. We have 2,790 Buffalo to Indianapolis moving company data points from the past 2 years that carry more weight.

Bayesian averages calculated to fairly account for the differences between companies that are newer(like Wayfinder Moving Services ) vs older more established companies (like Soft Touch Moving).

Hire Trusted Movers

The Great Guys Moving 11-Point Rating Breakdown

Our 11-point rating criteria scores every Buffalo to Indianapolis moving company across 11 of the most important criteria for a succesful moving experience.

Quality

Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.

8.37/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 2,625 reviews

Punctuality

Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?

8.07/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 761 reviews

Affordability

How affordable was the moving service?

7.24/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 370 reviews

Communication

Responsiveness before, during, and after the move.

7.41/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 816 reviews

Stick to Prices

Was the final price consistent with the original quote?

5.65/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 316 reviews

Speed

Efficiency without taking unnecessary time to increase costs.

8.55/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 1,057 reviews

Friendliness

Was the moving crew cordial and friendly on moving day?

8.98/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 1,503 reviews

Will Hire Again

How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again.

8.19/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 2,660 reviews

Professionalism

Did the moving crew behave professionally on moving day?

8.33/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 1,570 reviews

Conflict Handling

How well the company responds to accidents and issues.

3.91/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 323 reviews

Precision & Care

Were walls scratched? Did furniture get damaged or lost?

7.75/10 avg (Buffalo & Indianapolis combined) from 1,128 reviews

From Buffalo to Indianapolis: Comparable Neighborhoods at a Glance

• Elmwood Village in Buffalo & Massachusetts Avenue in Indianapolis are both known for their: walkable district with boutiques & nightlife
• Buffalo's Allentown neighborhood & Indianapolis' Fountain Square both share: arts district with galleries & live music
• If you're moving from North Park, check out Broad Ripple in the Indianapolis area for the: youthful scene with pubs & shops
• Do you enjoy Parkside's tree-lined streets with early 20th-century homes? You're sure to love Meridian-Kessler
• Move from South Buffalo to Bates-Hendricks and continue to enjoy these neighborhood qualities: working-class roots & riverside location
• West Side & Mapleton-Fall Creek are both known for their: revitalizing area near downtown & parks

Pros and Cons of Moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis

ConsBuffalo, NY

• Harsher winters
• Smaller city
• Higher taxes
• Less cultural diversity

ProsIndianapolis, IN

• Milder winters
• Larger city
• Lower taxes
• More cultural diversity

---

Indianapolis, IN

• Far from landmarks
• Less intimate
• Fewer local dishes
• Younger city vibe

Buffalo, NY

• Proximity to Niagara
• Close-knit community
• Unique local cuisine
• Richer history

Pros of moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis

• Say goodbye to harsher winters and hello to milder winters
• Look forward to moving away from a smaller city and moving to Indianapolis with a larger city
• Swap the higher taxes of Buffalo for lower taxes in Indianapolis
• Get ready for more cultural diversity in Indianapolis

Cons of moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis

• Unfortunately, you'll be moving away from proximity to Niagara in Buffalo to live far from landmarks in Indianapolis
• You'll lose out on the pro of a close-knit community and have to settle for the con of being less intimate
• Time to bid farewell to unique local cuisine and get used to fewer local dishes in Indianapolis
• Swap a richer history for a younger city vibe

Buffalo vs. Indianapolis: Comparing the Local Foodie Scene

If you're moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis, you will be trading the iconic Buffalo Wings of Buffalo for the equally delicious Pork Tenderloin Sandwich of Indianapolis. And while the locals in Buffalo rave about their flavorful Beef on Weck and sumptuous Speidies, Indianapolis residents know they have tasty Sugar Cream Pie and Corn on the Cob to savor. While the vegan transplants might be saying goodbye to the Tofu Wings they've grown to love, they can get ready for the Seitan Steak of Indianapolis. In the days before your move, make sure you get one final trip to iconic Buffalo eateries like Anchor Bar, Gabriel's Gate, and Duff's Famous Wings. After the boxes are unpacked in Indianapolis, don't wait too long before making your way to Indianapolis' acclaimed eateries like St. Elmo Steak House, Bluebeard, and The Eagle.

When comparing lifestyles, Indianapolis shows less emphasis on fitness and health consciousness than Buffalo. Food truck fans will discover a less desirable selection in Indianapolis compared to what you are used to in Buffalo. Also, the overall foodie scene is more bustling in Indianapolis.

Discover Indianapolis Restaurants You'll Love

Moving to Indianapolis is an opportunity to try lots of new restaurants. Sure, you'll miss your old Buffalo favorites, but we've got you covered. If you loved Gabriel's Gate, Anchor Bar, and Allen Burger Venture in Buffalo, we're sure you'll love King Dough, Ale Emporium, and Workingman's Friend in Indianapolis. See our Indianapolis restaurant discovery table below to find the closest comparison restaurant to all of your cherished Buffalo hotspots. For example, if you enjoyed dining at Marble + Rye, head to Bluebeard on your first Friday night after the boxes are unpacked.

Real Estate & Lifestyle Differences between Buffalo and Indianapolis

• The Victorian and Craftsman architecture that Buffalo is known for will be replaced with the Ranch and Colonial architecture typical of Indianapolis.
• Compared to Buffalo's real estate listings that commonly reference proximity to parks and waterfront views, Indianapolis real estate listings often highlight features like spacious yards and closeness to highways.
• You can keep your walking shoes packed away; Indianapolis is less walkable than Buffalo.
• Make sure the movers take care of your bike; Indianapolis is more bike-friendly than Buffalo.
• Indianapolis has less of an urban feel than Buffalo.
• Indianapolis housing costs are 3% more expensive than they are in Buffalo, with a median home price of $224,099 compared to Buffalo’s $216,997.
• Over the prior 5 years, home prices in Indianapolis have increased by 60% compared to a 66% increase in Buffalo.
• Rent in Indianapolis is 4.88% more expensive than in Buffalo.

Pet-friendly Neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN

1. Broad Ripple: You'll find this vibrant neighborhood perfect for pets with its abundance of parks, pet-friendly businesses, and walking trails.
2. Fountain Square: This eclectic area offers a pet-loving community with numerous outdoor events and dog-friendly establishments.
3. Meridian-Kessler: You're sure to enjoy the spacious yards and tree-lined streets that are ideal for daily walks and outdoor pet activities.

Your Move, Your Forecast: Key Weather Differences between Buffalo and Indianapolis

• Break out the sunglasses for your move from Buffalo to Indianapolis. Indianapolis gets 20% more sunshine days than Buffalo.
• Indianapolis has lower humidity and a higher average UV index compared to Buffalo.
• Say goodbye to the possible snowstorms and blizzards in Buffalo and be on the lookout for potential tornadoes and severe thunderstorms in Indianapolis.
• Get ready for warmer summers. The average summer high temperature in Indianapolis is 5 degrees warmer than in Buffalo.
• The average winter lows are 1 degree warmer than they are in Buffalo.
• Your umbrella might be more overworked in Indianapolis. Indianapolis receives 2 more inches of rain compared to Buffalo.

Financial & Community Snapshot: Buffalo and Indianapolis

• When it comes to your monthly paycheck, residents in Indianapolis tend to earn about 44% more than in Buffalo
• The COLI in Indianapolis is 9% lower than what you are used to living in Buffalo
• The state income tax in Indiana is 3.23 compared to 6.33 (average) in New York
• The affluence in Indianapolis is moderate to high compared to moderate in Buffalo
• The poverty level is moderate in Indianapolis compared to significant in Buffalo
• In terms of homelessness, it is moderate in Buffalo and low to moderate in Indianapolis

Political and Religious Climate in Buffalo vs. Indianapolis

• Buffalo tends to lean largely Democratic in its political climate
• Indianapolis, on the other hand, is often described as moderate, with both Democratic and Republican representation
• Indianapolis' religious environment can be described as a diverse religious landscape, with Christianity prevalent but with a growing representation of other faiths
• Buffalo's residents' religious practices can be generally categorized as Christianity dominant, with a strong Catholic presence

Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Traffic and Public Transit Considerations

• Bummer! Looks like you might end up spending about 14% more time stuck in traffic commuting to work in Indianapolis compared to your Buffalo commute. That's 1560 minutes lost each year in a car.
• You can expect traffic in Indianapolis to be worse than it is in Buffalo.
• Public transit is less readily available in Indianapolis.