Best Islandia Movers
Want help with the heavy lifting?
Updated Jun 8, 2025
Looking for reliable Islandia movers? See our top 10 recommended movers in Islandia, NY based on extensive analysis. We analyzed 40 moving companies in Islandia across 50,119 review data points and more than 18,000 movers nationwide using our 11-point rating system to help you determine which Islandia moving company to hire. See the top 10 Islandia movers, get data-based information on Islandia moving costs, the cheapest movers in Islandia, and our top recommendation for Long distance movers.
Key Takeaways:
- Blue Collar Moving is our overall top recommended moving company in Islandia
- Blue Collar Moving is the most affordable movers in Islandia
- Expect to spend somewhere between $1,396 and $2,594 on local Islandia moving services
- Our rankings and results are unbiased & backed by data… NOT paid promotions
Best Moving Companies in Islandia, NY
| Rank | Company | Score | BBB Rating | Avg Move Duration | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Blue Collar Moving | 9.66 | A+ | 7.25 hours | |
| 2 | Zippboxx | 9.37 | NR | 3.5 hours | |
| 3 | Piece of Cake Moving & Storage | 9.17 | B | 3 hours | |
| 4 | Fidelity Transportation Inc. | 9.10 | C- | 3 hours | |
| 5 | Small Moves Long Island | 9.06 | A+ | - | |
| 6 | Dunbar Moving | 8.90 | NR | 6 hours | |
| 7 | KP Quality Inc | 8.63 | NR | - | |
| 8 | Relocators | 8.62 | A+ | 4 hours | |
| 9 | Liberty Moving & Storage | 8.33 | A+ | 5 hours | |
| 10 | Molloy Bros Moving And Storage | 8.29 | A+ | 7.5 hours |
Our Top Recommendations
Blue Collar Moving
Middle, CT, 06269
11-Point Rating
Best moving company overall in Islandia, NY. Blue Collar Moving takes the #1 spot for our overall ranking and is the top recommended movers in Islandia.
Blue Collar Moving is the number 1 ranked moving service in Islandia, NY with an overall score of 9.66 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 100% of all movers in New York and the top 99.73% of moving companies nationwide. Blue Collar Moving is also one of the top 100 movers nationwide (out of more than 18,000 total moving companies).
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Blue Collar Moving & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.83 | ↑ 18.4% | 210 | 1 | 99.5% | |
| Punctuality | 9.86 | ↑ 23.6% | 107 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Affordability | 9.72 | ↑ 28.4% | 58 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Communication | 9.74 | ↑ 31.0% | 94 | 1 | 98.9% | |
| Stick to Prices | 9.77 | ↑ 63.8% | 52 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Speed | 9.86 | ↑ 16.8% | 92 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 9.89 | ↑ 13.2% | 148 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.77 | ↑ 21.4% | 212 | 2 | 99.1% | |
| Professionalism | 9.87 | ↑ 20.7% | 152 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Conflict Handling | 8.18 | ↑ 101.1% | 10 | 1 | 90.9% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.78 | ↑ 23.4% | 112 | 1 | 99.1% |
Recent Blue Collar Moving Reviews
Quality - 9.83/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.86/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 9.72/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 9.74/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 9.77/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.86/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.89/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.77/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.87/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 8.18/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.78/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Blue Collar Moving
- No services determined
Licenses
We do not currently have license data to display for Blue Collar Moving
Detailed Customer Insights
Based on our analysis of Blue Collar Moving's customer reviews:
7.25 hrs
Local Move Duration
based on 8 reviews
Zippboxx
923 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY, 11788
11-Point Rating
Zippboxx is the number 2 ranked moving service in Islandia, NY with an overall score of 9.37 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 95.48% of all movers in New York and the top 97.02% of moving companies nationwide. They score better than 38 other Islandia moving companies and better than 986 movers in New York.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Zippboxx & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.68 | ↑ 16.6% | 190 | 4 | 97.9% | |
| Punctuality | 9.65 | ↑ 20.9% | 62 | 1 | 98.4% | |
| Affordability | 8.99 | ↑ 18.6% | 37 | 2 | 94.9% | |
| Communication | 9.53 | ↑ 28.2% | 63 | 2 | 96.9% | |
| Stick to Prices | 9.06 | ↑ 51.9% | 28 | 2 | 93.3% | |
| Speed | 9.77 | ↑ 15.7% | 52 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 9.82 | ↑ 12.5% | 121 | 1 | 99.2% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.71 | ↑ 20.7% | 194 | 3 | 98.5% | |
| Professionalism | 9.76 | ↑ 19.3% | 144 | 2 | 98.6% | |
| Conflict Handling | 7.48 | ↑ 83.8% | 10 | 2 | 83.3% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.61 | ↑ 21.2% | 81 | 2 | 97.6% |
Recent Zippboxx Reviews
Quality - 9.68/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.65/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 8.99/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 9.53/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 9.06/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.77/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.82/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.71/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.76/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 7.48/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.61/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Zippboxx
- Local movers
- Long Distance Movers
- Storage
- Junk It
- Piano movers
- Office movers
Licenses
State & federal license information
USDOT Interstate License
Status: Authorized for Interstate Moves (last checked 8/10/24)- USDOT: 3077817
- MC: 1043860
- ENTITY TYPE: Carrier
6
Registered Trucks, Tractors, or Vans
6
Registered Drivers
3/14/24
Most Recent USDOT Update
1
Annual Interstate Miles (2024)
Detailed Customer Insights
Based on our analysis of Zippboxx's customer reviews:
3.5 hrs
Local Move Duration
based on 3 reviews
2 days
Interstate Move Duration
based on 5 reviews
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage
287 Park Ave S, New York City, NY, 10010
11-Point Rating
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage is the number 3 ranked moving service in Islandia, NY with an overall score of 9.17 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is an Exceptional score and places it in the top 92.4% of all movers in New York and the top 93.41% of moving companies nationwide.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Piece of Cake Moving & Storage & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 9.57 | ↑ 15.2% | 5,855 | 309 | 95.0% | |
| Punctuality | 9.63 | ↑ 20.6% | 2,384 | 109 | 95.6% | |
| Affordability | 9.23 | ↑ 21.9% | 1,436 | 117 | 92.5% | |
| Communication | 9.45 | ↑ 27.2% | 2,569 | 172 | 93.7% | |
| Stick to Prices | 8.34 | ↑ 40.0% | 717 | 160 | 81.8% | |
| Speed | 9.74 | ↑ 15.3% | 3,035 | 99 | 96.8% | |
| Friendliness | 9.78 | ↑ 12.0% | 3,080 | 78 | 97.5% | |
| Will Hire Again | 9.45 | ↑ 17.4% | 5,337 | 352 | 93.8% | |
| Professionalism | 9.45 | ↑ 15.6% | 3,032 | 207 | 93.6% | |
| Conflict Handling | 6.93 | ↑ 70.5% | 351 | 169 | 67.5% | |
| Precision & Care | 9.28 | ↑ 17.0% | 2,841 | 256 | 91.7% |
Recent Piece of Cake Moving & Storage Reviews
Quality - 9.57/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 9.63/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 9.23/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 9.45/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 8.34/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 9.74/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 9.78/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 9.45/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 9.45/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 6.93/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 9.28/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Recent Customer Praises
Recent Customer Complaints
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Piece of Cake Moving & Storage
- 24/7/365 Moving
- Local Residential Moving Services
- Long Distance Moving Services
- Office and Commercial Moves
- Small Moves
- Last Minute Moves
- Full Packing
- Platinum Packing
- Plastic Bin Hire
- Piano Moving
Licenses
State & federal license information
USDOT Interstate License
Status: Authorized for Interstate Moves (last checked 6/24/25)- USDOT: 3066988
- MC: 58659
- ENTITY TYPE: Carrier/Broker
293
Registered Trucks, Tractors, or Vans
215
Registered Drivers
4/24/25
Most Recent USDOT Update
7,410,040
Annual Interstate Miles (2024)
Detailed Customer Insights
Based on our analysis of Piece of Cake Moving & Storage's customer reviews:
2 hrs
Hourly Minimum
based on 4 reviews
3 hrs
Local Move Duration
based on 447 reviews
2 days
Interstate Move Duration
based on 178 reviews
Average Cost
$1,396.00
based on 66 historical data points
Fidelity Transportation Inc.
Long Beach, NY, 11561
11-Point Rating
Small Moves Long Island
Rockville Centre, NY, 11570
11-Point Rating
Dunbar Moving
8 Meadow Dr, Stony Brook, NY, 11790
11-Point Rating
KP Quality Inc
Hempstead, NY
11-Point Rating
Relocators
335 Kennedy Dr, Hauppauge, NY, 11788
11-Point Rating
Liberty Moving & Storage
350 Moreland Rd, Commack, NY, 11725
11-Point Rating
Molloy Bros Moving And Storage
185 Price Pkwy, Farmingdale, NY, 11735
11-Point Rating
How Much Do Movers Cost in Islandia, NY?
The average moving cost in Islandia, NY is $1,777, which is based on an analysis from 102 customer reports across 6 different moving companies. In general, expect to pay somewhere between $1,396 and $2,594 for a typical move.
- Median Reported Cost: $1,777
- Expected Range: $1,396 - $2,594
- Expected Time To Complete: 3 hours
- See detailed Islandia Moving Costs for a full breakdown
| COMPANY | MEDIAN REPORTED MOVING COST | AVG MOVE DURATION |
|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Transportation Inc. | $485 | 3 hours |
| Piece of Cake Moving & Storage | $1,396 | 3 hours |
| Tri-State Area Movers | $1,714 | 4.25 hours |
| U-Pack | $1,839 | - |
| College Hunks Hauling Junk & Moving | $2,594 | 3 hours |
| Liberty Moving & Storage | $4,628 | 5 hours |
*Please be aware that the listed prices derive from historical customer feedback spanning several years and might not mirror the exact current rates of a company. Additionally, the anticipated cost range provided represents the 25th to 75th percentiles from the comprehensive reports of all Islandia-based companies in our dataset.
How we ranked the top Islandia movers
Why you should trust us
We take reviews seriously to protect people just like you! Our team has been crunching data on moving companies since 2010. Our math-based ranking system uses data, manual review, and statistical analysis to help you hire the best movers in Islandia, NY.
Rating Methodology
Here's the methodology we used to come up with the best movers in Islandia:
Our original review-based ranking algorithm
We started with a total of 40 companies that offer moving services in the Islandia area.
From these 40 companies, we analyzed a total of 12,777 reviews dating all the way back to June 2009.
We also reviewed a total of 0 state and federal moving licenses from these 40 companies and 146 different 3rd party review and social profiles.
Each of the ~12,000 reviews was scored according to our detailed 11-point rating criteria
This gave us a total of 50,119 data points to compute individual company scores.
Reviews are time-weighted so that more recent reviews carry more weight. This helps you understand how a mover is doing today... not 5 years ago. We have 18,736 Islandia moving company data points from the past 2 years that carry more weight.
Bayesian averages calculated to fairly account for the differences between companies that are newer(like Fidelity Transportation Inc.) vs older more established companies (like Liberty Moving & Storage).
The Great Guys Moving 11-Point Rating Breakdown
Our 11-point rating criteria scores every Islandia moving company across 11 of the most important criteria for a succesful moving experience.
Quality
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Punctuality
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Affordability
How affordable was the moving service?
Communication
Responsiveness before, during, and after the move.
Stick to Prices
Was the final price consistent with the original quote?
Speed
Efficiency without taking unnecessary time to increase costs.
Friendliness
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly on moving day?
Will Hire Again
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again.
Professionalism
Did the moving crew behave professionally on moving day?
Conflict Handling
How well the company responds to accidents and issues.
Precision & Care
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get damaged or lost?
Charts & Visualizations
With 50,119 data points across 40 moving companies and 12,777 reviews, we've got a lot of data to work with. Here are some of the charts and visualizations we've created to help you understand the moving industry in Islandia.
Comparing ratings, review history, and total data points
Bubble size represents the number of analyzed data points. Hover over bubbles for details.
Ranking history
How the currently ranked top 10 Islandia movers have performed over time
11-Point Rating Comparison
Detailed breakdown of Islandia moving company 11-point ratings
New York-wide 11-Point Percentile Comparison
See how the top movers in Islandia compare to all movers in New York
 Quality |  Punctuality |  Affordability |  Communication |  Stick to Prices |  Speed |  Friendliness |  Will Hire Again |  Professionalism |  Conflict Handling |  Precision & Care | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Blue Collar Moving Exceptional9.66 | 98 | 99 | 99 | 98 | 100 | 97 | 98 | 98 | 99 | 97 | 98 |
2 | Zippboxx Exceptional9.37 | 93 | 94 | 78 | 94 | 93 | 93 | 95 | 97 | 96 | 94 | 92 |
3 | Piece of Cake Moving & Storage Exceptional9.17 | 87 | 93 | 90 | 95 | 85 | 95 | 94 | 86 | 81 | 96 | 80 |
4 | Fidelity Transportation Inc. Exceptional9.10 | 74 | 84 | 99 | 78 | 95 | 70 | 87 | 78 | 75 | 78 | 96 |
| 5 S | Small Moves Long Island Exceptional9.06 | 75 | 71 | 73 | 80 | 93 | 51 | 41 | 72 | 62 | -- | 88 |
| 6 D | Dunbar Moving Superb8.90 | 87 | 79 | 96 | 57 | 87 | 87 | 88 | 85 | 85 | 58 | 72 |
| 7 K | KP Quality Inc Fabulous8.63 | 63 | 71 | 71 | 73 | 79 | 62 | 58 | 65 | 71 | 59 | 74 |
8 | Relocators Fabulous8.62 | 77 | 75 | 39 | 79 | 55 | 68 | 77 | 78 | 83 | 73 | 87 |
9 | Liberty Moving & Storage Very Good8.33 | 66 | 70 | 30 | 68 | 57 | 52 | 62 | 63 | 71 | 61 | 60 |
| 10 M | Molloy Bros Moving And Storage Very Good8.29 | 54 | 66 | 36 | 68 | 72 | 50 | 68 | 53 | 65 | 51 | 57 |
Percentile Ranking
List of All Islandia Moving Companies Analyzed
See all of our Islandia moving company reviews
- Piece of Cake Moving & Storage
- Molloy Bros Moving And Storage
- Celebrity Moving Inc
- KP Quality Inc
- Blue Collar Moving
- College Hunks Hauling Junk & Moving
- Hall Lane Moving and Storage
- Tri-State Area Movers
- Liberty Moving & Storage
- Fidelity Transportation Inc.
- Relocators
- Moving and Storage Center of Long Island
- U.M.C. Moving Company, Inc.
- Small Moves Long Island
- Zippboxx
- Bay Shore Moving & Storage, Inc.
- U-Pack
- Dunbar Moving
- Hillside Van Lines
- The Piano Mover
- The Box Moving Company Inc.
- Samonas Prime Moving & Storage Inc.
- Zippy Shell Moving & Storage of Long Island
- PODS Moving & Storage
- North American Van Lines
- Phase 3 Movers
- 1-800-PACK-RAT Moving and Storage
- In N Out Movers Corp
- Triple Crown Warehouse - Moving & Storage Company
- Freedom Moving and Storage
- UNITS Moving & Portable Storage Long Island
- Jcm Movers
- Quality Moving and Storage
- C R Hamilton
- Long Island Pool Table Movers
- Corporate Transfer & Storage
- NuooEasy挪窝
- Relo Moving & Storage
- The Moving Doctor
- National Library Relocation
Frequently Asked Questions About Moving in Islandia
How much should you tip movers in Islandia, NY?
In Islandia, it’s common to tip around 10–20% of the total moving cost or about $5 per mover per hour to show appreciation for a job well done. Local movers often handle tight parking spaces near Veterans Memorial Highway or busy streets off the Long Island Expressway, so a fair tip helps acknowledge their extra effort. As a thoughtful gesture, you might also offer something refreshing like an iced coffee to keep them going through the day.
Is it cheaper to make a DIY move in Islandia?
Tackling a DIY move in Islandia might save money up front, but be ready to cover costs for fuel, equipment rentals, and any extra supplies needed along the way. You’ll also want to plan for traffic, parking restrictions, and possible tolls on the local highways around Suffolk County. If you decide to rent a vehicle, check out local truck rental options to find a suitable ride for your do-it-yourself adventure.
Should I hire labor-only movers?
If you prefer a more hands-on approach for your Islandia relocation, hiring labor-only movers could be a perfect fit. You can rent a truck on your own and leave the heavy lifting to experienced professionals who know the ins and outs of Islandia’s neighborhoods and tricky driveways. This approach lets you stay in control of your move while still getting expert help where it’s needed most.
What if I need to move something special like a piano or pool table?
For larger or delicate items in Islandia—like pianos, pool tables, hot tubs, or even statues—you’ll want movers who specialize in handling these unique challenges. That’s where expert piano movers and pool table movers come in handy, especially if your New York home includes narrow stairwells or limited loading space. These professionals have the right equipment and know-how to protect your valuables during every step of the move.
