New York to Indiana Moving Guide

Pros and Cons of Moving from New York to Indiana

ConsNew York

• High cost of living
• Expensive housing
• High state taxes
• Crowded subways
• Traffic congestion
• Limited parking
• Noise pollution
• Small apartments
• Long commutes
• Tourist crowds
• Higher childcare costs
• Expensive groceries
• Frequent rent hikes
• Nor'easter disruptions

ProsIndiana

• Lower cost of living
• Affordable homes
• Lower state taxes
• Less crowded commutes
• Easier driving
• Ample parking
• Quieter neighborhoods
• Larger living spaces
• Shorter commutes
• Fewer tourists
• Lower childcare costs
• Cheaper groceries
• Stable housing costs
• Fewer coastal storms

---

Indiana

• Limited public transit
• Car-dependent living
• Fewer dining options
• Fewer museums
• Limited theater scene
• Earlier closing times
• Fewer direct flights
• Lower salary ranges
• Smaller job market
• Smaller professional scene
• Fewer marquee attractions
• Quieter nightlife
• Fewer niche shops
• Fewer big events

New York

• Extensive public transit
• Walkable neighborhoods
• World-class dining
• Top museums
• Broadway and theater
• 24/7 services
• Major airport choices
• High salary potential
• Diverse job sectors
• Networking opportunities
• Iconic attractions
• Late-night entertainment
• Specialty retail shops
• Frequent cultural events

Pros of moving from New York to Indiana

• Say goodbye to the high cost of living and hello to the lower cost of living
• Look forward to moving away from expensive housing and moving to Indiana with affordable homes
• Swap the high state taxes of New York for the lower state taxes in Indiana
• Get ready for less crowded commutes in Indiana

Cons of moving from New York to Indiana

• Unfortunately, you'll be moving away from extensive public transit in New York to live with limited public transit in Indiana
• You'll lose out on the pro of walkable neighborhoods and have to settle for the con of car-dependent living
• Time to bid farewell to world-class dining and get used to fewer dining options in Indiana
• Swap top museums for fewer museums

New York vs. Indiana: Comparing the Local Foodie Scene

If you're moving from New York to Indiana, you will be trading the iconic Bagel with Lox of New York for the equally delicious Pork Tenderloin Sandwich of Indiana. And while the locals in New York rave about their flavorful Pastrami on Rye and sumptuous Hot Dog, Indiana residents know they have tasty Breaded Pork Cutlet and Elephant Ear to savor. While the vegan transplants might be saying goodbye to the Avocado Toast they've grown to love, they can get ready for the Vegan BBQ Seitan of Indiana. In the days before your move, make sure you get one final trip to iconic New York eateries like Katz's Delicatessen, Peter Luger Steak House, and Dominique Ansel Bakery. After the boxes are unpacked in Indiana, don't wait too long before making your way to Indiana's acclaimed eateries like St. Elmo Steak House, Bluebeard, and Milktooth.

When comparing lifestyles, Indiana shows less emphasis on fitness and health consciousness than New York. Food truck fans will discover a less desirable selection in Indiana compared to what you are used to in New York. Also, the overall foodie scene is less bustling in Indiana.

Real Estate & Lifestyle Differences between New York and Indiana

• The Pre-war and Brownstones architecture that New York is known for will be replaced with the Craftsman and Colonial architecture typical of Indiana.
• Compared to New York's real estate listings that commonly reference close proximity to public transport and high-rise apartment features, Indiana real estate listings often highlight features like spacious lots and family-friendly neighborhoods.
• You can keep your walking shoes packed away; Indiana is less walkable than New York.
• You might want to think twice before moving your bike; Indiana is less bike-friendly than New York.
• Indiana has less of an urban feel than New York.
• Indiana housing costs are 49% less expensive than they are in New York, with a median home price of $236,990 compared to New York’s $460,812.
• Over the prior 5 years, home prices in Indiana have increased by 54% compared to a 36% increase in New York.
• Rent in Indiana is 45.99% more affordable than in New York.

Your Move, Your Forecast: Key Weather Differences between New York and Indiana

• The shades won't be used as much for your move from New York to Indiana. Indiana gets 17% fewer sunshine days than New York.
• Indiana has higher humidity and a higher average UV index compared to New York.
• Say goodbye to the possible hurricanes and nor'easters in New York, but be on the lookout for potential tornadoes and severe thunderstorms in Indiana.
• The average summer high temperature in Indiana is 1 degree warmer than New York.
• The average winter lows in Indiana are 6 degrees colder than they are in New York.
• Your umbrella might be neglected in Indiana. Indiana receives 7.7 fewer inches of rain compared to New York.

Financial & Community Snapshot: New York and Indiana

• When it comes to your monthly paycheck, residents in Indiana tend to earn about 16% less than those in New York
• The COLI in Indiana is 10% lower than what you are used to living in New York
• The state income tax in Indiana is 3.23% compared to 6.85% in New York
• The affluence in Indiana is moderate compared to high in New York
• The poverty level is low in Indiana compared to moderate in New York
• In terms of homelessness, it is significant in New York and minimal in Indiana

Political and Religious Climate in New York vs. Indiana

• New York tends to lean Liberal/Democratic in its political climate
• Indiana, on the other hand, is often described as Conservative/Republican, with rural areas leaning more heavily
• Indiana's religious environment can be described as predominantly Christian, with a significant Protestant population
• New York's residents' religious practices can be generally categorized as multicultural and diverse

How Much Do New York to Indiana Movers Cost?

Moving 712 miles from New York to Indiana will typically cost between $2,500 and $5,500 to hire full service movers. See the chart below for a detailed breakdown by home size.