Movers

Indiana to New York Moving Guide

Updated June 23, 2025

Hero background image

Planning a 713 mile interstate move from Indiana to New York? This moving guide will help you compare living in Indiana vs New York across 7 important categories. Compare the pros & cons, food & health (like Pork Tenderloin Sandwich vs Bagels and Lox), real estate & housing (ranch, colonial vs colonial, modern high-rise), weather & wardrobe, cost of living & taxes (it's more expensive in New York), politics & religion, and education.

Key Takeaways:

  • Say goodbye to Pork Tenderloin Sandwich and Beef Manhattan, but get your taste buds ready for Bagels and Lox & New York Strip Steak
  • New York housing costs are 94% more expensive than they are in Indiana
  • Rent in New York is 85.16% more expensive than in Indiana
  • Moving from Indiana to New York will cost on average between $1,500 - $5,500
  • Our top recommended Indiana to New York movers is JP Urban Moving

Indiana vs. New York: Comparing the Local Foodie Scene

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Most iconic local food itemPork Tenderloin SandwichBagels and Lox
Most popular meat dishBeef ManhattanNew York Strip Steak
Most popular street food itemCorn DogsPizza
Most popular vegan foodTempeh ReubenVegan Bagel
Top 3 iconic restaurants that summarize the state
  • St. Elmo Steak House
  • Bluebeard
  • The Loft at Traders Point
  • Katz's Delicatessen
  • Le Bernardin
  • Shake Shack
Fitness/Health ConscientiousnessπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺπŸ’ͺ
Abundance of Food Trucks🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚
Foodie Scene🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴
Vegan Friendly🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱

If you're moving from Indiana to New York, you will be trading the iconic Pork Tenderloin Sandwich of Indiana for the equally delicious Bagels and Lox of New York. And while the locals in Indiana rave about their flavorful Beef Manhattan and sumptuous Corn Dogs, New York residents know they have tasty New York Strip Steak and Pizza to savor. While the vegan transplants might be saying goodbye to the Tempeh Reuben they've grown to love, they can get ready for the Vegan Bagel of New York. In the days before your move, make sure you get one final trip to iconic Indiana eateries like St. Elmo Steak House, Bluebeard, and The Loft at Traders Point. After the boxes are unpacked in New York, don't wait too long before making your way to New York's acclaimed eateries like Katz's Delicatessen, Le Bernardin, and Shake Shack.

When comparing lifestyles, New York shows a greater emphasis on fitness and health consciousness than Indiana. Food truck fans will discover a greater selection in New York, compared to what you are used to in Indiana. Also, the overall foodie scene is more bustling in New York.

Real Estate & Lifestyle Differences between Indiana and New York

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Typical Architecture StyleRanch, ColonialColonial, Modern High-Rise
WalkabilityπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘ŸπŸ‘Ÿ
Bikeability🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲
Urban LifestyleπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈπŸ›οΈ
Most popular items mentioned in real estate listingSpacious yards, Quiet neighborhoodsProximity to public transit, Views
  • The Ranch and Colonial architecture that Indiana is known for will be replaced with the Colonial and Modern High-Rise architecture typical of New York.
  • Compared to Indiana's real estate listings that commonly reference spacious yards and quiet neighborhoods, New York real estate listings often highlight features like proximity to public transit and views.
  • Make sure you unpack those walking shoes. New York is more walkable than Indiana.
  • Make sure the movers take care of your bike. New York is more bike-friendly than Indiana.
  • New York has more of an urban feel than Indiana.
  • New York housing costs are 94% more expensive than they are in Indiana with a median home price of $460,812 compared to Indiana’s $236,990.
  • Over the prior 5 years, home prices in New York have increased by 36% compared to a 54% increase in Indiana.
  • Rent in New York is 85.16% more expensive than in Indiana.

Your Move, Your Forecast: Key Weather Differences between Indiana and New York

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Days of Sunshine per Yearβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈβ˜€οΈ
Avg. Annual HumidityπŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦πŸ’¦
Avg. UV IndexπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈπŸ•ΆοΈ
Natural DisastersTornadoes, FloodsHurricanes, Blizzards
Air QualityModerateVariable
Average Summer High/Low (Β°F)85/6582/62
Average Winter High/Low (Β°F)35/2032/18
Annual Rainfall (Inches)4247
Annual Snowfall (Inches)2225-75 (Varies widely by region)
  • Break out the sunglasses for your move from Indiana to New York. New York gets 20% more sunshine days than Indiana.
  • New York has lower humidity and a lower average UV index compared to Indiana.
  • Say goodbye to the possible tornadoes and floods in Indiana, but be on the lookout for potential hurricanes and blizzards in New York.
  • The average summer high temperature in New York is 3 degrees colder than in Indiana.
  • The average winter lows are 2 degrees colder than they are in Indiana.
  • Your umbrella might be more overworked in New York. New York receives 5 more inches of rain compared to Indiana.

Financial & Community Snapshot: Indiana and New York

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Avg. Household Income$66,785$79,557
Cost of Living Index92.95102.8
State Income Tax3.234-8.82
Avg. Property Tax0.871.4
Avg. Sales Tax78.875
Top 3 IndustriesManufacturing, Agriculture, Health CareFinance, Media, Tourism
AffluenceModerateHigh
PovertyLowModerate
HomelessnessLowHigh
  • When it comes to your monthly paycheck, residents in New York tend to earn about 19% more than in Indiana
  • The COLI in New York will be 11% higher than what you are used to living in Indiana
  • The state income tax in NY is 4-8.82 compared to 3.23 in IN
  • The affluence in New York is high compared to moderate in Indiana
  • The poverty level is moderate in New York compared to low in Indiana
  • In terms of homelessness, it is low in Indiana and high in New York

Political and Religious Climate in Indiana vs. New York

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Political Make-upLean RepublicanLean Democratic
Local PoliticsMixed, with rural areas trending more RepublicanUrban areas strongly Democratic, rural areas more Republican
ReligionChristianity predominant, Evangelical strong presenceDiverse, with Christianity dominant but more pluralistic religious landscape
  • Indiana tends to lean Republican in its political climate
  • New York, on the other hand, is often described as lean Democratic
  • New York's religious environment can be described as diverse, with Christianity dominant and a more pluralistic religious landscape
  • Indiana's residents' religious practices can be generally categorized as Christianity predominant, with a strong Evangelical presence

Education Guide When Moving from Indiana to New York

ComparisonIndianaNew York
Where most Seniors go to college (top 3)Indiana University
Purdue University
Ball State University
New York University
Columbia University
Cornell University
Top 3 Elementary SchoolsSmoky Row Elementary (Carmel)
Cedar Elementary (Avon)
Prairie Trace Elementary (Carmel)
Success Academy Charter School (Brooklyn)
Scarsdale Union Free School District (Scarsdale)
Jericho Union Free School District (Jericho)
Top 3 Middle SchoolsWest Lafayette Jr/Sr High School (West Lafayette)
Brown County Jr High School (Nashville)
Sidener Academy for High Ability Students (Indianapolis)
East Side Middle School (New York City)
Rye Neck Middle School (Mamaroneck)
I.S. 187 The Christa McAuliffe School (Brooklyn)
Top 3 High SchoolsSignature School (Evansville)
Carmel High School (Carmel)
West Lafayette Jr/Sr High School (West Lafayette)
Bronx High School of Science (Bronx)
Stuyvesant High School (New York City)
Townsend Harris High School (Flushing)
Top 3 private high schoolsCulver Academies (Culver)
Park Tudor School (Indianapolis)
Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School (Indianapolis)
Horace Mann School (Bronx)
Collegiate School (New York City)
Trinity School (New York City)
Top 3 private K-12 schoolsUniversity High School (Carmel)
The Orchard School (Indianapolis)
Traders Point Christian Academy (Whitestown)
Riverdale Country School (Bronx)
The Spence School (New York City)
The Brearley School (New York City)
Top 3 School DistrictsCarmel Clay Schools
West Lafayette Community School Corporation
Munster School Corporation
Jericho Union Free School District
Great Neck Public Schools
Scarsdale Union Free School District

How Much Do Indiana to New York Movers Cost?

Moving 713 miles from Indiana to New York will typically cost between $2,500 and $5,500 to hire full service movers. See the chart below for a detailed breakdown by home size.

  • Expected Range: $2,500 - $5,500
  • Expected Time To Complete: 2-7 days
  • Most Affordable Recommended Movers: Magical Moving & Storage
HOME SIZEMOVING COSTVOLUME OF PACKED ITEMS (FT3)$/FT3
Studio$1,607300 ft3$5.36
1 Bedroom$2,388450 ft3$5.31
2 Bedrooms$3,942750 ft3$5.26
3 Bedrooms$5,7261100 ft3$5.21
4 Bedrooms$8,2491600 ft3$5.16
5+ Bedrooms$9,1901800 ft3$5.11

Top Indiana to New York Movers

Read our in-depth analysis of the best Indiana to New York movers with detailed rankings, cost breakdowns, and reviews.

TOP PICK
JP Urban Moving featured image

JP Urban Moving

Best moving company overall for Indiana to New York

9.85/10
ExceptionalView details
RUNNER-UP
Metropolis Moving featured image

Metropolis Moving

9.72/10
ExceptionalView details
ALSO GREAT
MVM Moving & Storage featured image

MVM Moving & Storage

9.23/10
ExceptionalView details