Carney-Mcnicholas Review
Looking to hire Carney-Mcnicholas? See our detailed 11-point review based on our independent analysis of Carney-Mcnicholas, 35 other Youngstown moving companies, and 558 moving companies in Ohio.
Carney-Mcnicholas has an overall score of 7.75 out of 10. Based on our extensive analysis, this is a Good score and places it in the top 58.21% of all movers in Ohio and the top 52.4% of moving companies nationwide. They score better than 324 movers in Ohio.
Key Takeaways:
- Overall rating: 7.75 out of 10
- Highest 11-point rating category: Friendliness
- Our rankings and results are unbiased & backed by data… NOT paid promotions
About
Carney-McNicholas is a premier moving company that has been serving families and businesses since 1906. Over the decades, it has carried on a commitment to providing superior service no matter how big or small the moving job. Carney-McNicholas offers moving services that cover every logistical need - residential, commercial, local, and long-distance. It’s the go-to mover for Pennsylvania and Ohio because its all-in-one services give you flexibility and control over your relocation. Need more options for your move? You can find a wide array of quality moving companies in Youngstown, OH to serve your relocation needs. Carney-McNicholas provides traditional full-service moving solutions as well as a more tailored do-it-yourself service to assist with specific tasks you may need assistance with. Whether you need professional packing services, custom-crating, labor-only service, or even storage solutions - Carney-McNicholas offers it all.
Our Research
11 Point Rating
| Metric | Score Out of 10 | vs Nationwide Comparison between Carney-Mcnicholas & the average of all
moving companies nationwide | Positive Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric positively (a score of 7-10) | Negative Reviews The total number of reviews that rated the metric negatively (a score of 1-6) | Positive Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 8.59 | ↑ 3.5% | 13 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Punctuality | 7.07 | ↓ -11.4% | 1 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Affordability | 7.09 | ↓ -6.4% | 1 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Communication | 7.76 | ↑ 4.4% | 4 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Stick to Prices | 7.26 | ↑ 21.8% | 2 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Speed | 7.53 | ↓ -10.8% | 1 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Friendliness | 8.77 | ↑ 0.4% | 8 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Will Hire Again | 8.31 | ↑ 3.3% | 11 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Professionalism | 8.34 | ↑ 2.0% | 6 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Conflict Handling | 6.20 | ↑ 52.4% | 2 | 0 | 100.0% | |
| Precision & Care | 8.39 | ↑ 5.8% | 7 | 0 | 100.0% |
Recent Carney-Mcnicholas Reviews
Quality - 8.59/10
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Overall Review Distribution
Punctuality - 7.07/10
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Overall Review Distribution
Affordability - 7.09/10
How affordable was the moving service?
Overall Review Distribution
Communication - 7.76/10
Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?
Overall Review Distribution
Stick to Prices - 7.26/10
Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?
Overall Review Distribution
Speed - 7.53/10
Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!
Overall Review Distribution
Friendliness - 8.77/10
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?
Overall Review Distribution
Will Hire Again - 8.31/10
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.
Overall Review Distribution
Professionalism - 8.34/10
Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?
Overall Review Distribution
Conflict Handling - 6.20/10
Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.
Overall Review Distribution
Precision & Care - 8.39/10
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?
Overall Review Distribution
Additional Details
Moving Services Offered by Carney-Mcnicholas
- Residential Move
- Commercial Move
- International Move
- Storage
- Office Moving Services
- Moving Containers
- Corporate Relocation
- Packing Services
- Shipment Protection
- Free, no-obligation moving estimates
Licenses
State & federal license information
USDOT Interstate License
Status: Authorized for Interstate Moves (last checked 6/27/25)- USDOT: 465059
- MC: 149444
- ENTITY TYPE: Carrier
2
Registered Trucks, Tractors, or Vans
6
Registered Drivers
9/14/23
Most Recent USDOT Update
125,000
Annual Interstate Miles (2022)
Detailed Customer Insights
We do not currently have insights to display for Carney-Mcnicholas
Error. Please try again later.
Awards
Contact Carney-Mcnicholas
- 100 Victoria Rd, Youngstown, OH, 44515
- (330) 792-5460
- https://cmcn.com/
Follow Carney-Mcnicholas:
How we ranked the top Ohio movers
Why you should trust us
We take reviews seriously to protect people just like you! Our team has been crunching data on moving companies since 2010. Our math-based ranking system uses data, manual review, and statistical analysis to help you hire the best movers in Ohio.
Rating Methodology
Here's the methodology we used to come up with the best movers in Ohio:
Our original review-based ranking algorithm
We started with a total of 558 companies that offer moving services in the Ohio area.
From these 558 companies, we analyzed a total of 81,863 reviews dating all the way back to October 2007.
We also reviewed a total of 189 state and federal moving licenses from these 558 companies and 1,788 different 3rd party review and social profiles.
Each of the ~81,000 reviews was scored according to our detailed 11-point rating criteria
This gave us a total of 196,235 data points to compute individual company scores.
Reviews are time-weighted so that more recent reviews carry more weight. This helps you understand how a mover is doing today... not 5 years ago. We have 25,456 Youngstown moving company data points from the past 2 years that carry more weight.
Bayesian averages calculated to fairly account for the differences between companies that are newer.
The Great Guys Moving 11-Point Rating Breakdown
Our 11-point rating criteria scores every Ohio moving company across 11 of the most important criteria for a succesful moving experience.
Quality
Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.
Punctuality
Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?
Affordability
How affordable was the moving service?
Communication
Responsiveness before, during, and after the move.
Stick to Prices
Was the final price consistent with the original quote?
Speed
Efficiency without taking unnecessary time to increase costs.
Friendliness
Was the moving crew cordial and friendly on moving day?
Will Hire Again
How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again.
Professionalism
Did the moving crew behave professionally on moving day?
Conflict Handling
How well the company responds to accidents and issues.
Precision & Care
Were walls scratched? Did furniture get damaged or lost?
